Fashion, Lifestyle, Opinion

Tess Holliday’s Cosmopolitan Photo shoot: Fatphobia at Large

0 232

By Shawna Healey


The term ‘intersectional feminism’ was coined by critical race theorist Kimberle Crenshaw, professor of Law at UCLA and Colombia Law School, in a 1989 paper “Demarginalizing the Intersection of Race and Sex: A Black Feminist Critique of Antidiscrimination Doctrine, Feminist Theory and Antiracist Politics”. Intersectionality is centered around analysing how oppression often intersects – for example, race and gender intersect when black women earn less, on average, than black men, but also earn considerably less than white women. Originally, the term was focused on the discrimination that black women face – not just sexism and racism, but the marginalisation of black womanhood generally – which is now referred to as “Misogynoir”.

Today, intersectional feminism extends to anyone who identifies with social, cultural and biological groups that are not favoured in a patriarchal, capitalist, white supremacist society. Many people who identify as feminists recognise intersectionality, and actively try to promote inclusivity and diversity, fight against “-isms”, and unlearn ingrained behaviours that might go against their belief in diverse feminism. This includes body positivity, often abbreviated to #bodiposi online.

The movement of body positivity has been around since the late 1960s, when author Lew Louderback’s essay “More People Should be Fat” was published in the Sunday Evening Post. Since then, body positivity has taken many different shapes, and has been commodified time and time again by various companies. Dove’s Real Beauty is a famous example. The movement has, however, also been met with criticism. In an interview with USA Today, activist Caleb Luna said: “I find it’s been co-opted by the mainstream to be like ‘love your body as long as it’s underneath a size 12, and you don’t have any visible scars, you don’t have any acne and you wax all your body hair off’.” This exemplifies how many people believe in body positivity only to an extent. The term ascribed to this seeming hatred of fat people and fat bodies is ‘fatphobia’, something which most if not all people, including fat people themselves, battle with to some degree, as the idea of thinness as the “ideal body” is deeply ingrained into Western culture.

Recently, there has been uproar on social media due to the fact that Tess Holliday, a plus-size model, was featured on the front page of Cosmopolitan magazine. Many people voiced their opinion on Twitter, with some people calling the cover an “unhealthy representation” and others proclaiming that “fat acceptance is NOT okay“. Some comments were particularly misogynistic and offensive: “The Cosmo model looks disgusting with her rolls and rolls of fat as did the “models” on this discussion today. The fact we have to many more plus-sized shops is a disgrace as its [sic] further proff [sic] we are now a nation of fat slobs!

It is essential that contemporary intersectional feminism challenges the patriarchal and Eurocentric beauty standards by which thinness is regarded as the only way to be beautiful, despite the fact that being underweight can be just as conducive to ill health as obesity. If we subscribe to the idea of body positivity, then this should include all bodies, including those that defy convention.

The existence of a fat person, especially the existence of a fat person in the mainstream media, is not a glorification obesity. It is a reality which should not be denied for the comfort of a general public bent on directing abuse towards people whose only offence is existing outside contemporary Western beauty standards. Tess’ front cover is inspirational – it shows that fat people can be and are beautiful, and we should all be applauding Cosmopolitan for being so forward-thinking and diverse. Body positivity is a powerful movement which strives to make everyone feel beautiful in their own skin, and this shouldn’t be limited to certain people with certain bodies – it should include everyone, even and especially Tess Holliday.


What do you think of Tess Holliday’s Cosmo cover and the #bodyposi movement? Join the conversation over on Twitter @aAh_mag

About the author / 

Shawna Healey

I'm Shawna, 20 and Welsh studying Geography at MMU. I have varying interests and opinions but usually its all things feminism.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More News Stories:

  • Manchester’s toxic air: what are we doing about it?

    By Ben Townsend Have you experienced any coughing fits recently? How about itchy eyes or an irritated nose? It might not just be hay fever. According to Clean Air Greater Manchester (GM), these can also be the effects of toxic air pollution — one of the biggest health risks in the city today. More worryingly, air pollution…

  • Review: TORUK – The First Flight

    Written by Mike Hingston For years I personally believed that James Cameron had a near spotless record of productions with one exception being the 2009 film Avatar. I was left feeling disappointed with this film despite its amazing and awe inspiring graphics due to what felt like a lack of substantial narrative. For years the…

  • Spotlight On + Interview With Baltikk

    By Camilla Whitfield Introducing Baltikk, the latest band planning on topping the indie charts. Formed in October 2017, the Manchester-based five-piece is made up of vocalist Harry Edwards, drummer Sam Sumner, Daniel Littlemore on the bass, and last but certainly not least, guitarists Joe Ball and Kyle Bebb. Despite having only recently emerged, however, this…

  • Interview: The Cast of TORUK

    By Mike Hingston TORUK – The First Flight is a show inspired by James Cameron’s AVATAR, and created by Cirque du Soleil. The world premiere was held in Montreal in December 2015 and the show has been touring the world ever since. Following our preview earlier this month, aAh! were given the opportunity to speak…

aAH! Radio