By Rosa Methol
Once again, representations of disability have this week hit the headlines, with disability rights activists protesting at the UK premiere of Jojo Moyes’ film adaptation of her bestselling book, Me Before You. The film has created an uproar on Twitter, with one user claiming that it is responsible for “setting back disability right by 30 years,” and another demanding “When are you going to reflect our real lives?”
The film tells the story of a supposedly unlikely relationship between carer Lou, played by Emilia Clarke, and Will, who became quadriplegic after a car accident, played by Sam Claflin. Previous to their meeting, Will has decided that he wants to kill himself due to his new life with a disability and has applied to go to the assisted suicide clinic in Switzerland, Dignitas.
This is not the first time that films have presented suicide as the ‘best’ option for severely disabled people. There is an on-going motif in films about disabled people that it is better to die than to continue to live with an intrusive disability. Disability is routinely used as an emotive plot feature and so it is understandable that one twitter user wrote, “I’m not your inspiration porn and I’m not a thing to be pitied or killed off to make the audience cry.”
The film has also met criticism for its casting of a non-disabled actor to play the role of Will, Sam Claflin not having any physical disabilities in real life. Similarly to The Theory of Everything, which depicts able-bodied actor Eddie Redmayne as Stephen Hawking, many disability rights activists have said that Me Before You is guilty of enabling “cripping up”, or the act of pretending to be disabled for entertainment purposes.
In a video of the premiere protest, activists can be seen chanting “Rights not Tragedy” to the bemusement of the film’s writer Jojo Moyes, who was apparently unprepared for this response. She told activist and actress Liz Carr, “I have to say, in all the years, I’ve never had anyone that shares your views.”
The lasting message of these protests is not that disabled people who are also suicidal do not exist, but rather that the consistent representation of disability as tragic or worse than death is insulting, and more than a little ‘done’. In the same way that racist and sexist cinematic misrepresentations are routinely challenged, reductive portrayals of the lives of disabled people are simply not acceptable in this day and age.
Through the arches of aged brick and rusting iron beams stands a new window of opportunity, honouring Manchester’s industrial pioneering of the past, while looking forward to the city’s essentially eco-conscious future. In the historical neighbourhood of Castlefield, a 330-metre long viaduct has stood undisturbed and derelict for decades. After becoming overrun by nature’s due…
Featured image: Georgina Hurdsfield Let’s see what July has in store for us as we round up the best events of the month… Kicking off aAh!’s listings for July is Festival Manchester 2022, the city’s largest free music festival dedicated to our community. We’ve also rounded up our favourite music festivals taking place across the UK,…
The 2022 QuietManDave Prize is open to entries until 1st July The QuietManDave Prize is back once again, honouring the life of Dave Murray and his beloved blog, with Dima Alzayat, Kate Field and Shane Kinghorn taking the judging helm. Among the entries of 500 words or less, there are numerous prizes up for grabs,…
As the submission deadline for the 2022 QuietManDave Prize steadily approaches, yet again we are presented with a unique opportunity for flash literature-lovers and aspiring writers all over the world. The competition honours the life of Dave Murray and his beloved blog (of which the awards found its name), a theatre critic, open-mic poet and…
Leave a reply