Entertainment, Review

Doctor Who Series 9 Review: Under the Lake

0 125

By Jack Rea


The nights are getting darker and colder, and for some reason Doctor Who is being broadcast later, so now feels like the perfect time for the show to introduce a spooky ghost story. After an intense and explosive opening two-parter, Doctor Who slows down the pacing and reintroduces a well-established format for the show; essentially a base under siege.

There was little room for breathing in the Magician’s Apprentice and Witch’s Familiar, with the episodes feeling a little overstuffed with various returning companions and arch-enemies. This week we get the chance to be introduced to a whole host of new characters for the Doctor and Clara to save. Some of these work and some don’t. Those that become ghosts early on in the episode are given little to no development but this is necessary for the plot to create a threat for the surviving crew. Highlights have to be the new female members of the cast. O’Donnell is both a smart and funny member of the team, attempting to hide her admiration of the Doctor. Cass, portrayed by deaf actress Sophie Stone is excellent in her authoritative role holding the team together and assisting the Doctor in putting the pieces together. This perhaps shouldn’t have to be worthy of comment but it’s very good to see such a powerful non-speaking part on television. The male members of the crew have been written so far as stereotypical frightened guys, ready to run at the first chance, but I remain optimistic that next week with the cast split into two different locations (and times) we can see a bit more from them.

Visually this series of Doctor Who is on a roll, the shimmering floating ghosts are very eerie from the ominous repetitive chanting to the deep set holes for eyes. The set itself is also superb, giving a real sense of claustrophobia to the characters trapped deep under water. Next week looks set to be very different in setting and tone, with the Doctor emerging from the lake above ground. It’s good to see the programme using the two-parter format in such an efficient way, with two distinct halves to the story. The sonic sunglasses are back and apparently now officially part of Doctor Who mythology. I have to admit they work juxtaposing Peter Capaldi’s serious and alien incarnation of the Doctor but I can’t imagine them being pulled off by many other actors. How long they’ll endure remains to be seen.

The episode presents the ghosts as a real threat early on as they send an unfortunate member of the crew to a watery grave, however I feel later in the narrative the story seems to undermine their threat. They seem a little too easily tricked by a Clara hologram and trapped in a room of the base. When the Doctor steps into the room and they are unable to do him harm it presents them as rather useless. The water itself seems to present more of a threat as various corridors begin to fill up. Not only is it the reason for the death of the before-mentioned character but it also definitively separates the Doctor and Clara from each other (whilst giving Peter Capaldi the opportunity to do an Indiana Jones style roll underneath a closing door.) It’ll be interesting to see how Clara handles next week without the Doctor, particularly as I have a feeling the ghosts won’t stay trapped for long. Much has been made of Clara assuming a Doctor-like role in the show recently and this week we get the Doctor himself addressing the fact. He essentially tells her to calm down and not to go “native.” Clara’s willingness to place herself in danger at the moment is only adding to my building sense of dread.

Finally the show hits us with yet another massive cliff-hanger. The Doctor is a ghost now apparently and it seems next week’s purpose is to tell us how he died trying to save everyone. I admire the story’s ambition and find it on the whole effective and scary but I’m starting to slightly tire of plots surrounding the Doctor’s impending death. At least it gave us a chance to see Peter Capaldi in creepy ghost mode. That’s an image which is sure to give many young viewers nightmares.

Jack is a third year English student and self-proclaimed Whovian who also enjoys film and live music. You can read his blog here – Jack Rea Blog

About the author / 


aAh! Magazine is Manchester Metropolitan University's arts and culture magazine.

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More News Stories:

  • Opinion: “Our real legacy at university is the friends we make along the way”

    We all prioritise different things in life: our relationships, academic achievement, and financial success. While these can be great catalysts for short and long-term goals, making us resilient,  fixating on these goals can become overwhelming, even detrimental. Focusing on what we feel we have to achieve can make it easy to lose sight of the…

  • Reading and Leeds Festival 2024: The best bands to see this year

    Featured image: Georgina Hurdsfield Overwhelmed by the sheer magnitude of choice on offer at this year’s Reading and Leeds Festival? Don’t worry, we’ve got you. We’ve trawled the lineups to bring you a cluster of acts to watch on the August bank holiday weekend. From jungle to riotous punk, there’s a bounty of brilliant bands…

  • Film Review: The Idea of You – A sappy feel-good rom-com

    Featured image: PA Media In this sappy, heart-warming rom-com, two lovers meet at Coachella as Solène (Anne Hathaway) takes her daughter to a meet and greet at the Californian music festival. Known for her iconic roles in The Devil Wears Prada (2006) and The Princess Diaries (2001), Hathaway plays the role of a 40-year-old divorcee…

  • Travel: Tips for multi-country trips abroad while keeping your bank account happy

    Featured image: Georgia Pearson The summer break from university is approaching and conversations about travel plans can be heard across campus. But with the cost of living at a high, students and young people are looking for cheaper ways to travel this summer. Travelling to multiple countries during one trip can be a budget-friendly way…