If It Ain’t Broke, Don’t Fix It

0 264

Dr Melanie Latham presenting her research lecture

Cosmetics or cosmetic surgery? Tummy crunch or tummy tuck? Boost bra or boob job? In the words of Manchester Metropolitan University’s (MMU) Dr Melanie Latham “If it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.” This is the title of her meticulously researched lecture focusing on the 2010 scandal in France surrounding PIP breast implants. Even four years after the scandal took place, thousands of women are still affected by the health problems it created. With 90% of surgery cases being women and a lot of media coverage of women getting cosmetic surgery deemed unnecessary by the public on the NHS, the battle between natural beauty and cosmetic perfection is ongoing. Is the falsity replacing the reality?

The subject of cosmetic surgery was the fourth series of lectures included in the Humanities in Public programme (HiP) at MMU. This part of the programme aims to explore the reasons many women have cosmetic surgery. Dr Latham argues that improvements should be made in the UK to make cosmetic surgery safer and more patient orientated, emphasising ‘patient autonomy’.

Dr Melanie Latham presenting her research lectureThere is no doubt that cosmetic surgery is big business. While buy-one-get-one-free Botox may seem a joke to some of us, this deal is as familiar as buy-one-get-one-free shampoo or face-cream in some surgeries, but Dr Latham argues that these treatments are not only “risky and invasive, but also health threatening.” – Why? The answer was made obvious in the PIP implant case, which focused attention on the health issues surrounding cosmetic surgery. Women were given breast implants that may have been toxic, and were five times more likely to rupture. When this was discovered, the French government offered all French women who had had these implants free removal. However, in the UK no such offer was made. Dr Latham argues that women were let down by their government and by their surgeons who would claim there was no actual evidence as to the toxicity of these implants. However, Dr Latham pointed out that this case opened people’s eyes to the risks of cosmetic surgery and she hoped this ‘will lead to much needed regulation’, describing this as the ‘good news’.

 As the floor opened up to questions, it was clear that many people were opinionated, interested and educated upon the matter as it was ‘enhanced’ from a Q & A session to a full blown discussion in which the word ‘vanity’ was juggled and assessed. There was a sigh from the eager audience when it was announced this would be the last question.

Dr Latham’s talk definitely ended on a high note as her avid listeners left discussing and debating all the way out the doors, clearly eager for the next talk in the HiP series by Dr Ruth Holiday on Monday. It shed light upon the ‘cutting edge’ issues surrounding cosmetic surgery that are often shrouded in myth and secrecy in an honest tone that bears all: no nips and tucks here, ladies.

Lucy Simpson is a prospective journalist who is passionate about reading, writing and eating chocolate. You can read more of her work on her blog.

About the author / 


Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More News Stories:

  • Neighbourhood Festival 2019: The 5 Unmissable Acts You Need To See

    Along with the emergence of darker nights and Starbucks’ infamous Pumpkin Spice Lattes arrives the annual Neighbourhood Festival on the 12th of October. Last year the festival pulled huge crowds in with stellar headliners ‘Everything Everything’ and ‘Sundara Karma’. This year offers to be no different, boasting over 15 venues and more than a hundred…

  • Highlights: Sunday @ Leeds Fest 2019

    Words and photography by Georgina Hurdsfield Sadly, it was the last day of Leeds Festival for 2019 but the day gave us plenty to look forward to. The perfect band to wake us up after listening to the sounds of Piccadilly Party all night, we decided to check out Leeds’ very own hardcore band, Higher…

  • Highlights: Saturday @ Leeds Fest 2019

    Words and photography by Georgina Hurdsfield After all the excitement of yesterday, we decided to start our day of with alt-pop Swimming Girls over on the BBC Introducing Stage which we deemed would be a more chill affair, however, we were very wrong. Swimming Girls pulled in a huge crowd which would be fit for…

  • Highlights: Friday @ Leeds Festival 2019

    Words and photography by Georgina Hurdsfield This year at Leeds Festival, something felt different to previous years. For starters, the weather forecast lived up to its predictions and the baking sun shone down on festival-goers all weekend. Recycling bins are seen in all directions, extinction rebellion video messages are playing throughout the festival highlighting the…

aAH! Radio