Captain Phillips : Fearless or Feckless? - aAh! Magazine

Entertainment, News

Captain Phillips : Fearless or Feckless?

1st November 2013 By aAh! 0 220

Words by Lisa Burns

Captain Richard Phillips has been immortalised in Hollywood’s latest Oscar-nomination-grabbing outing. Captain Phillips was released in the UK on 18th October, and is a real edge-of-your-seat affair.

A slow starter, it follows the real-life story of merchant mariner, Phillips, as he heroically handles the situation of his Maersk cargo ship Alabama being taken hostage by Somali pirates. As the first half of the film unfolds, we see a representation of Phillips as a natural leader, a placid family man, professional to a tee. We then see his masterful leadership of his brave crew in the hostage situation.

The viewer cannot but look on with a mixture of horror and admiration as Phillips heroically offers himself as a Christ-like sacrificial victim in exchange for the freedom of his crew. The second half of the film gives a moment-by-moment account of Phillips’ experiences as the sole hostage in the ship’s claustrophobic lifeboat.

Barkhad Abdi

The really interesting story, however, is the one that unfolds when you take a look at the REAL Captain Phillips. The film is based on Phillips’s autobiography, A Captain’s Duty: Somali Pirates, Navy SEALS and Dangerous Days at Sea, which Columbia Pictures bought the rights to in 2009.
As the film was promoted and Phillips was re-thrust into the limelight, his detractors also emerged from the woodwork – but from perhaps the unlikeliest of places: his own crew.

A member of the Alabama crew (who spoke anonymously for legal reasons) said, ‘Phillips wasn’t the big leader like he was in the movie. No one wants to sail with him’. The crew member also claimed that the real Phillips refused to follow through with the anti-piracy protocol, declaring, ‘he was real arrogant.’ These claims are the complete opposite of the events retold in the film.

Richard Phillips - Rooftop: A Captain's Duty

It emerges that engineer Mike Perry, who has a small part in the film, may actually have been the real hero of the situation. He had the crew hide in the ship’s boiler room and managed to attack one of the pirates in an attempt to ensure Phillips’s safety. Some reports have branded Phillips as irresponsible and reckless with the lives of his crew; though how much of this is jealousy or an attempt to steal some of his,
perhaps deserved, limelight, is ultimately speculation.

Whoever the real Captain Phillips is, the film is thought-provoking, entertaining and certainly well worth a watch. I’ll let you decide as to whether Phillips deserves the title of hero.

Lisa Burns studies History and English at MMU. When she’s not got her nose in a book, she loves having adventures in the great outdoors! Follow her on Twitter: @LittleRobin09

About the author /

aAh!

aAh! Magazine is Manchester Metropolitan University's arts and culture magazine.

A Captains' Duty: Somali Pirates Abduwali Muse Barkhad Abdi Captain Phillips Hollywood hostage Maersk Alabama Mike Perry Navy SEALS Navy SEALS and Dangerous Days at Sea Oscars Somali pirates Tom Hanks

Leave a reply Cancel

29th May 2026
Fcukers @ New Century Hall gallery – bringing the party to Manchester

Featured image and gallery: Lucy Elson-Whittaker Fcukers headline a sold-out show at Manchester’s New Century Hall, in support of their long-awaited debut album, ‘ö’. Opening the night are Sydney-based Sleepazoid, whose hazy, atmospheric sound offers a sharp contrast to the headliners’ explosive energy. Their set feels cinematic and dream-like, serving as both a striking opener…
21st May 2026
Q&A: DR DR on Manchester, Justin Timberlake and full-fat milk

Featured image and gallery: Sub Khan Hailing from Manchester and playing a sold-out show at Manchester’s Lion’s Den, with an imminent EP on the way, aAh! speaks to Fred Farrell (vocals) and Danny Atherton (bass) of Dr Dr. Did you start the band during Covid times? Is that where it all originated? F: It was…
16th May 2026
Yellow Days @ Gorilla review – a night of cinematic neo-soul

Featured image: Gary Walker Neo-blues soul artist Yellow Days, the stage name of Haslemere’s George van den Broek, returns to Manchester with his seventh album, Rock And A Hard Place, and a live show that proves just how far he has come. Before he steps out, London-based act Brian Nasty warms the room up nicely,…
12th May 2026
The Royston Club @ O2 Victoria Warehouse gallery: sending shivers down your spine

Featured image and gallery: Sally Stretch The Royston Club perform alongside Overpass and Permanent (Joy) at a sold-out O2 Victoria Warehouse. Welsh indie rock band The Royston Club, school friends who began playing together in 2017, now headline O2 Victoria Warehouse in Manchester. Touring second album Songs For The Spine, they generate an energetic sold-out…