Music, News, Review

Thrice @ Manchester Academy review – revisiting a post-hardcore classic

0 129

Featured image: Matty Vogel


Palm Reader are dab hands at this. They’re a slick machine let down by a mix that congeals their three guitars into one gloopy, soupy mess. Still, it doesn’t stop the Nottingham band from throwing themselves around, with bassist Josh Redrup circling his hand above his head before the breakdown in ‘Swarm’, as if to signal a wrestler’s finishing move. Aside from a small compliant patch of converts at the front, it’s a commandment that goes unheeded.

Frontman, Josh McKeown, cuts a frustrated figure. His between-song patter borders on the sarcastic, cementing their lack of cut-through. The final insult comes during closer, ‘A Bird and its Feathers’. One wag shouts, “Go on, then!”, while waiting for a big finish that doesn’t follow its promising build-up. An off night.

Just ten days shy of the 20th anniversary of their first Manchester show, Thrice are back to celebrate their landmark The Artist in the Ambulance album. A masterclass in early ‘00s post-hardcore, it’s one of the genre’s defining releases. Two decades on, its alchemy of aggression and immediacy remains uneclipsed.

To lend the Californian quartet an added air of mystique, the Academy’s smoke machine goes apoplectic, meaning they’re obscured in fog by the time they tear into ‘Cold Cash and Cold Hearts’. An army of fists puncture the clouds, mirroring each beat of Riley Breckenridge’s kick drum, which threatens to do the same to the audience’s abdomens. Surrounded by fluorescent light tubes that flash through the whole colour spectrum, it’s clear the affection Thrice hold for the album. Dustin Kensrue, anchored to the spot, attacks his guitar with the same vigour as his vocals, while Teppei Teranishi is a flurry of activity as he plucks out a series of intricate riffs.

Midway through a world tour, you could forgive them for holding something back. They don’t. ‘Stare at the Sun’ and the hefty ‘Paper Tigers’ keep the momentum going, with the occasional crowd surfer taking to the waves. The double-edged sword of album shows is that you know what’s coming next, so there’s a mini exodus to the bars once the title track shuttles out of earshot. 

The second half of the set is a hopscotch through Thrice’s ten other studio albums. A supercharged rendition of ‘Deadbolt’ from 2002’s The Illusion of Safety reawakens long dormant synapses, but this is a group who have never shackled themselves to any one sound. Smoothing out those hardcore roots made the latter-day likes of ‘Black Honey’ and ‘The Dreamer’ possible, the latter prompting one excitable gent to clamber onto his friend’s shoulders to howl along like a vertical panto horse.

This evolution is key to their longevity. Breadth and depth, rather than chasing a long departed zeitgeist.

About the author / 

Ian Burke

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More News Stories:

  • Spaces to connect and grow: Ten places to find your community in Manchester

    Featured image: Adomas Lukas Petrauskas Manchester thrives on its diverse communities – cultures, clubs and networks that bring people together. Whether you’re new to the city, looking to find your place at university or simply hoping to make some new friends, there’s a group for you. From walking clubs to creative workshops, we’ve rounded up…

  • Student experience: “Leaving home taught me how to find a community”

    Featured image: Natalie Bhart Homesickness hits different when you’re 10,000 miles away. I’ve always hated the cold, so it’s a good thing that summers back home in Brisbane, Australia are practically year-round. Now, three weeks into my student exchange at Manchester Metropolitan University, I’m still trying to adjust to the seemingly persistent rain and freezing…

  • “People will hold your hand and then watch you fly:” Musician Ellen Beth Abdi on Manchester’s creative community

    Featured image: Jodi Hartley Manchester’s musical history is nothing short of legendary. Between Joy Division’s post-punk innovations, Britpop royalty Oasis and the booming indie rave scene that sparked ‘Madchester’, the city has been a stomping ground for some of the most influential artists in British music history. Now, festivals like Parklife and OUTBREAK continue to…